Cuddalore, Another Bhopal: Bhopal Activist says
PRESS RELEASE
CHENNAI, 16 December, 2006 -- SIPCOT Cuddalore is
another Bhopal in the making because the conditions that led to the
1984 Bhopal disaster are very visible even in SIPCOT, said Satinath
Sarangi, a prominent member of the International Campaign for Justice
in Bhopal, and managing trustee of Sambhavna Clinic which provides free
medical treatment to gas victim. Mr. Sarangi was keynote speaker at a
meeting organized by Community Environmental Monitoring at Madras
Institute of Development Studies titled "Ongoing Human Rights
Violations in Cuddalore." Outlining the conditions, Mr. Sarangi said
the Bhopal disaster happened because a hazardous unit was located in a
residential area populated by working class people who were politically
and socially disadvantaged. Another symptom that indicates a high
likelihood of dangerous pollution is where the Government or regulators
ignore community and worker complaints, and pay little heed to
pollution incidents.
Prof. S. Ramachandran, Vice-chancellor Madras University, presided
over the meeting, and accepted the first copy of a report titled "Why
Cuddalore is Another Bhopal: An Analysis of Environmental, Safety and
Regulatory Infrastructure in SIPCOT Chemical Complex." The report
documents a total of 72 environmental and legal violations in a 26
month period between October 2004 and November 2006, involving 12
injured workers and 5 persons who lost their lives. The report confirms
that there is a major hazardous incident or legal violation every two
weeks in SIPCOT, Cuddalore. If serious incidents of bad chemical odour
are taken into account, the average increases to 75 hazardous incidents
every month.
The report finds the response of regulatory authorities - notably,
the Tamilnadu Pollution Control Board and the Inspector of Factories -
to be dismal. "Out of 72 incidents, complains were sent on 70
occasions, whereas action has been taken only in 14 instances. Of these
14, in three instances, the action was so delayed as to make it
irrelevant." Community members who lodged the complaint were contacted
by the regulatory agency only in 7 cases of 70.
"Beware! Governments will assure you that all precautions will be
taken. Companies will promise jobs and zero discharge. In the
long-term, you'll only have disease -- no clean water, no hospitals, no
jobs, no justice -- just like the Bhopalis", he said. "Don't allow
polluting industries such as the PVC factory or the oil refinery unless
you're prepared to struggle like we have been forced to for 20 or 30
years."
Chemplast Sanmar's PVC plastic factory that will handle thousands of
tons of highly explosive vinyl chloride monomer is being located right
next to a factory manufacturing rocket fuel for India's space research
facility. The factories are barely 200 metres from residential areas.
Till date no information has been released on the extent of potential
damage in the event of a disaster. Representatives from West Gonur
Farmers Welfare Association said that several thousand acres of fertile
farmland and several hundred wells were laid waste by pollution from
Chemplast's PVC and chemicals factories in Mettur. A representative of
Manali Youth Exnora spoke about how the petrochemical refinery and
thermal power plant in Ennore-Manali has deprived people of their
livelihoods, and impoverished local communities rather than improve the
economy. Mr. Sundaram, a farmer from Sirumugai, condemned the move to
locate textile dyeing units in Cuddalore's farmlands, and recounted the
experience of Bhavani basin farmers who saw their lands degrade as a
result of surface and groundwater pollution by textile units.
Fisherfolk representatives from South Indian Fisher Welfare
Association, Tamilnadu Fisherfolk Development Organisation and
Fishermen Liberation Movement pledged their support to Cuddalore
fisherfolk who recently issued a resolution against the PVC factory and
other polluting industries in Cuddalore.