This month Mexico's
giant state-owned oil company, Pemex, is Privatizing
the first of dozens of plants in a region that some environmentalists view as a
potential Love Canal. Concern is mounting that Pemex will simply use the sale to hand over an
environmental time bomb before it explodes. PNS associate editor Joel Simon's
book "Bordering on Destruction: Exploring Mexico's Environmental
Crisis," will be Published by Sierra Club Books next year.
COATZACOALCOS,
MEXICO -- Eusebio Gonzalez, a grizzled 66-year-old fisherman, hardly
ventures into the polluted Coatzacoalcos River
anymore. Chemicals dumped by Pemex petrochemical
plants have wiped out most of The fish, he says, and
those which have survived are not fit to eat.
"You cut the fish open and a smell like ammonia comes
out," says Gonzalez, sitting in front of a quiet boathouse. "If you
eat it, your stomach swells like a balloon. Still, we have to sell it. What
else are we going to live on?"
This month, one of the four massive petrochemical plants
which are responsible for most of the pollution in the Coatzacoalcos River will be auctioned off. Altogether
61 plants scattered across the country will eventually be sold. The sale marks
the first-ever privatization of a division of Pemex (Petroleos Mexicanos), the giant
state owned oil industry, long a bedrock of Mexican national pride.
Some environmentalists are hoping the sale will pave the way
for a Major environmental cleanup of the plants by new owners. Others fear Pemex will simply use the sale as an excuse to wash its
hands of the environmental disasters it has left behind, in effect handing over
an environmental time bomb before it explodes.
"We're hopeful this will be an opportunity to develop a
plan to deal With the hazardous waste," says
Betty Ferber, international coordinator for the Mexico City based Group
of 100. "But at the same time we're worried that Coatzacoalcos could become a Mexican Love
Canal."
No studies have been done on the long-term health risks in
the region, the heart of Mexico's
once thriving petrochemical industry, but no one who can help it eats the fish
caught in the river. The Coatzacoalcos receives more than 1
million cubic meters of waste water each day. A decade ago it regularly caught
fire. Fishermen report that their nets bring up
yellow, gelatinous sediment from the river bottom.
Meanwhile, farmers complain that their wells have been
poisoned and Their crops damaged by acid rain. Ezekiel
Ulzes Garcia, who lives near one of the four plants
up for sale, is organizing a group of farmers who claim their crops have been
destroyed by toxic runoff. "The corn doesn't grow, the coconuts don't
ripen, and the children get sick from drinking water from the well," Ulzes complains, standing over a fetid pool of polluted
water that has collected near his wooden shack.
"Have you ever seen it rain oil from the sky?"
asks Lorenzo Bozada Robles, a biologist and expert on
the region's pollution. "One day it started to rain like any other day.
Then I realized it was not water, it was oil ... People were sliding around
falling down in the street."
While environmentalists debate the impact privatization
could have on The region, other observers fear the
high cost of dealing with the damage will scare off future investors
altogether.
To reassure buyers, Pemex recently
carried out environmental audits to determine the areas where the plants are in
violation of Mexican environmental law. Investors can then incorporate those
costs into their bids.
George Baker, a Mexican oil industry analyst, argues that
many plants are so obsolete that they will require enormous investments to
bring them up
to international standards. "If you are going to go through all the
trouble to rebuild the plants, you might as well do it right and be in
compliance with environmental regulations," says Baker.
Julia Carabias, Mexico's top
environmental official, says however that the audits were limited to
determining compliance with existing law. Pemex
itself has no plans to clean up the Coatzacoalcos region.
"How could we ask Pemex to
remediate everything?" Carabias asks.
"They'd have to remediate the whole country, and we wouldn't accomplish
anything."
The audits themselves describe a plethora of environmental
problems, including emissions of sulfur, carbon monoxide, and ammonia into the
air, and dumping of chlorides, benzene, acids and oil into the river, according
to Homero Aridjis,
President of the Group of 100, who obtained copies.
Even then, Pemex officials would
only allow inspection of the super-modern Morelos
plants where engineers painstakingly explained the anti-contamination systems
and defended Pemex's environmental record. Pemex's other plants, which lack such basic amenities as
scrubbers and water treatment facilities, were off limits. A Pemex official in Mexico City
claimed that the refinery in Minatitlan which was visibly
sending plumes of steam into the air was "not operating."
At a time when Mexico is desperately trying to
attract foreign investment, few observers expect that whatever companies do
decide to buy the plants will be required to clean them up.
"Environmental laws are being eroded under
Zedillo," says Maria Elena Mesta Fernandez, an
attorney with the Mexican
Center on Environmental
Law. "The government's program is to attract foreign investment at all
cost."
She pointed to the government's decision to no longer
require environmental impact studies for most industries. Coatzacoalcos biologist Bozada
fears that the privatization scheme will transfer valuable public assets into
private hands while the people of Coatzacoalcos will be left to deal
with the mess Pemex leaves behind.
"During all the years I was fighting against Pemex I never lost faith that one day it would be a clean
company, with responsible executives a patrimony of the nation," Bozada says. "Never in my wildest dreams did I think
they would sell off the industry."
|